The cast of the third season of You keeps growing.

We don’t complain about it – especially when Scott Michael Foster joins the cast – but every new announcement just makes us more nervous for our favorite creepy buddy to return.

Foster, who was recently known for playing Nathaniel Plimpton II on Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, will play Ryan, a local television reporter. According to Deadline, he is “a popular single father who has overcome an addiction history. Ryan has secrets, including controlling, calculating behavior, that he reserves for those who are closest to him and anyone in his way.”

If a character on this show didn’t have dark secrets and calculated behavior, we’d be almost concerned.

Foster is the second beloved Scott to join you this season. Scott Speedman will also return as Matthew, a successful and mysterious CEO and father who masks a “deep source of emotion underneath”. Everyone on this show needs therapy!